Mastering Journal Growth: KPI Essentials for Journal Editors
By Alex Moerson
As a journal editor, understanding and using Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) is crucial to achieving your goals. While many of us are familiar with KPIs, it’s important to dig deeper into what they really mean for journal management and how you can make them work for your specific needs. In this post, we'll break down what KPIs are, how to decide on them, and what questions you should ask yourself along the way. Plus, we’ll share some practical examples to get you started.
What is a KPI?
In simple terms, a Key Performance Indicator (KPI) is a measurable value that shows you how well your journal is achieving its key goals. Think of it like a scoreboard for your journal’s success. But not all KPIs are created equal. Here are five key aspects that make a KPI effective:
Specific: The goal should be clear and well-defined—no guesswork here. The more focused the KPI, the easier it is for everyone to understand what’s expected.
Time-bound: Every KPI needs a deadline. Whether it's an overall target for the year or smaller milestones along the way, having a clear timeframe helps you track progress and stay on course.
Relevant: The KPI needs to directly tie into your journal's broader objectives. Make sure it's aligned with what you really want to achieve.
Attainable: Set goals that stretch your growth, but don’t make them impossible. Realistic KPIs keep everyone motivated and on track.
Measurable: You need to be able to track your progress—this way, you can celebrate wins and adjust strategies if things aren’t working out.
How Do You Decide on the Right KPIs?
Choosing the right KPIs can feel overwhelming, but don’t worry. It all comes down to knowing your journal’s unique needs and goals. Here’s a simple process to help you choose KPIs that make sense for your journal:
Know Your Journal: You’re the expert here. Your deep understanding of your journal’s strengths and challenges is invaluable when setting KPIs.
Do Some Research: Take time to analyze your journal’s past performance—what’s worked and what hasn’t? A SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats) can help you pinpoint areas that need attention and potential for growth.
Learn from the Past: Look at your historical data to see where you’ve succeeded before. Past performance is a great way to set realistic future targets.
Use the Right Tools: Leverage the data you have access to. If you don’t have much data, talk to your publisher about what reports they can provide.
Benchmark Against Others: Look at how your journal stacks up against others in your field. This will help you set competitive goals and ensure you’re keeping up with industry standards.
By following these steps, you’ll be able to set KPIs that are both informed and relevant to your journal’s mission.
Key Questions to Ask When Setting Your KPIs
While it’s easy to get caught up in numbers and metrics, it’s also important to step back and think about the bigger picture. Here are some key questions to guide you:
What areas of my journal need the most attention? This helps you prioritize where to focus your efforts.
What’s your journal’s biggest challenge right now? Tackling weaknesses head-on can lead to big improvements down the line.
What’s your long-term vision? Think of this as your “North Star.” Knowing where you want to be in 5 or 10 years will help you set goals that align with your ultimate vision.
Can you break your 5-year goals into smaller steps? Big goals can feel overwhelming but breaking them down into manageable chunks makes them easier to tackle.
Are your goals realistic? Make sure your KPIs are achievable with the resources you have.
What’s your timeline? Setting a timeline gives you a roadmap to follow, making it easier to track progress and make adjustments.
What steps do I need to take to hit my KPIs? Keep in mind that progress won’t always be linear. For example, if you want to increase submissions, you may first need to diversify your editorial board to reach new audiences.
Examples of KPIs for Journal Growth
To give you a clearer idea of what KPIs might look like for your journal, here are some examples focused on growth and content development:
Increase year-over-year (YOY) submissions: A growing number of submissions means more engagement with your journal.
Reduce YOY desk rejects: Fewer desk rejects signal higher-quality submissions coming in.
Increase YOY acceptance rate: A higher acceptance rate means your submissions are aligning better with the content you're looking for.
Increase YOY articles accepted: More articles accepted means more diverse content for your journal.
Increase YOY articles published: More articles published can improve the visibility and reach of your journal.
Increase YOY citation rate: A higher citation rate means your journal is having more impact in the field.
Increase YOY Downloads: More downloads means more people are reading the content you are publishing, which can help take into account clinical practice.
Apply for an impact factor or indexing: Achieving these milestones can significantly boost your journal’s reputation and reach. Look at relevant indexes in your discipline to make sure you are included.
These KPIs are all about improving both the quantity and quality of submissions, which can lead to stronger journal growth and a greater reputation in the field.
Conclusion: Stay Flexible
Setting KPIs that are both ambitious and realistic is key to a journal’s growth. It’s important to dream big, but also to set goals that are achievable with your current resources. And remember, if you find that your KPIs need tweaking midway through the year, it’s okay to adjust them. The most important thing is to stay flexible and adapt to your journal’s evolving needs.
By following these steps and keeping your goals clear and measurable, you’ll be well on your way to mastering journal growth.
About the Author
